posted: Jun. 18, 2020
A check of the city directories showed Casse Boccaccio there in 1989 (838 Broad Ripple Avenue [H4 on map
] where Condado Tacos is today) and Arthur's Music Store there in the 1970s, but no listings for the years in question, the 1990's.
An email to a long-time restaurant and bar owner produced the answer. It was J Bistro before Chumley's.